Harry Potter moives vs The Lord of the Rings movies

[Raoul Duke]

I think that if you look at both sets of movies, LOTR is far superior, but if you consider the movies as a representation of the novels then I think HP would win.

Sorta tricky though, because you have to ask yourself "what was the director's intertion?"

[Marina]

Who did I vote again?
Anywho...I think Harry Potter is the best pick, though I don't know if I picked HP

[dark_mg.girl-Mana]

I think HP is better

[Sanakan]

LOTR was better as a movie I think

HP was better book

[Mai]

I'm going to see harry potter the fourth movie...can't..wait..

LOTR was like a midevil soap opera.

[Gaming Goddess]

I'm going to see harry potter the fourth movie...can't..wait..

LOTR was like a midevil soap opera.

Soap Opera?!?!/!

[Mai]

I'm going to see harry potter the fourth movie...can't..wait..

LOTR was like a midevil soap opera.

Soap Opera?!?!/!

Lol! No..it's not a soap opera. It's a very serious and extremely great series!!

[Kenshin]

yea it was even better then harry Potter i bet and plus LOTR has Leglous

[dark_mg.girl-Mana]

Well they're even for now

[Kenshin]

not any more

[SnowAngel]

1 HP books
2 LOTR movies
3 HP movies

never read the LOTR books. the 4th HP movies looks good tho. ((2 more days!!))

[Pink Supervisor|EL]

first and for most the lotr book owned the lotr movies, you just have to read it... its only athousand pages os of text book sixed print... i think size 5-8...


1. LOTR book
2. LOTR movie
3. Starwars the original (eg. "luke i am your father")
4. HP book
5. HP movie

[bloom4419]

I like both of them but I think I prefer LOTR

[Duuz]

Lord Of The Rings only because I have no interest to see Harry Potter.

However to me Star Wars over Lord Of The Rings and Babylon 5 over everything.

[Gay = Sasuke Uchiha]

Both

[EGGz4life]

i love harry potter books more then the movies.

i love lord of the rings movies more then the books.

so i cant decide!!!