Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Discussions about anything movie or television-related

Witch is better?

Harry Potter
7
27%
Lord Of The Rings
19
73%
 
Total votes: 26

Pink Supervisor|EL
Absolute Otaku
Posts: 5579
Joined: Jul 20, 2005 10:34pm
Gender: Male
Location: ...where am i?...
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Pink Supervisor|EL »

both are good

but...

book->movie adaptation
the LOTR movie adaptated the books alot better then the HP movies (from what i can remember).

story Depth->
i think LoTR was wonderfully directed and the story and drama (and not only the fight scenes mind you) kept the story going. i'm giving this to LoTR

History->
again i'll give this to the LOTR Book series. THe sillmarillion (while like a text book) is an exellent source of the rich history of Middle earth, and is the backbone on how The Hobbit and the LOTR series builds apon.

Memoriability->
both have memorable scenes but the scenes in LOTR to me seem more dramatic and aweinspiring... i mean Pelanor feilds that was a kick ass assortments of scenes!

if they were to fight each other->
haha LOTR hand's down

Men of the Dead
Elven mages
Sauron (a demi-god)
the wizard order (demi-gods with locked away power)
sword of griffindor get's owned by Andurial XD even sting
Assassin of the Black Knights
Naru-chan's hubby50 YEN FEE TO CALL ME PINK
PINOY PRIDE ^_^
I'm in Dispair! (insert random social problem here) has left me in dispair!
akhilesh_king
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 168
Joined: Mar 13, 2007 7:30pm
Location: Australia

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by akhilesh_king »

Lord of the Rings gets my vote.... the movie(s) are the best.... nothing like that could be ever made again.... i doubt it anyway... :mrgreen:
...its all good all the time...
akhilesh_king
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 168
Joined: Mar 13, 2007 7:30pm
Location: Australia

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by akhilesh_king »

Lord of the Rings gets my vote.... the movie(s) are the best.... nothing like that could be ever made again.... i doubt it anyway... :mrgreen:
...its all good all the time...
ZeianStar
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 155
Joined: Apr 27, 2007 12:11pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Inner World
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by ZeianStar »

So everybody like LOTR better. For me I can't really decide.
In Weyard train with Isaac, Garet, Felix, Mia, Ivan, Jenna.
Gorby
Full Metal Otaku
Posts: 272
Joined: Jan 04, 2005 3:23pm
Location: In a dark part of the universe
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Gorby »

animaniac wrote:like hello do you not watch south park??
Kyle(dressed as a paladin): What are you guys doing?

Other Kid: We're playing Harry Potter

Cartman (dressed as Gandalf): HA!!! FAGS!!!!
I may not be a school but Im getting an extention program in my pants
User avatar
animaniac
Uber Otaku
Posts: 723
Joined: Jun 02, 2006 6:33am
Location: Aussie Aussie Aussie!!!

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by animaniac »

Gorby wrote:
animaniac wrote:like hello do you not watch south park??
Kyle(dressed as a paladin): What are you guys doing?

Other Kid: We're playing Harry Potter

Cartman (dressed as Gandalf): HA!!! FAGS!!!!
ahahah HI FIVE! :heh:
-AA Sibs: Rosemary-sama, saiko, rinslet, Fay D. flourite, Koyue, sakura-kiss, shio (my lovely), Brokenheart, lawliet, ashitaka, zippidy ^^, lenfa(filo sis 4 life)
-AA twin:Wolfgang
-AA biatch:Neo
DJ ÑÎÑJÅ
Visitor

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by DJ ÑÎÑJÅ »

Too bad they both suck, really. o_O
Puppy
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 158
Joined: Mar 22, 2007 4:26pm
Gender: Female

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Puppy »

um,I guess Lord Of The Rings
iRawr.
ZeianStar
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 155
Joined: Apr 27, 2007 12:11pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Inner World
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by ZeianStar »

No I don't watch South Park.
In Weyard train with Isaac, Garet, Felix, Mia, Ivan, Jenna.
angelofdarkness
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 159
Joined: May 10, 2007 5:28pm
Gender: Female
Location: w/ yami
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by angelofdarkness »

i like both of them
http://www.animegalleries.net/img/187606 dedicated to my grandpa 1931-2008
ZeianStar
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 155
Joined: Apr 27, 2007 12:11pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Inner World
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by ZeianStar »

Well.....The Golden Compass and Eragon were also good like Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings.
In Weyard train with Isaac, Garet, Felix, Mia, Ivan, Jenna.
ZeianStar
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 155
Joined: Apr 27, 2007 12:11pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Inner World
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by ZeianStar »

Well.....The Golden Compass and Eragon were also good like Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings.
In Weyard train with Isaac, Garet, Felix, Mia, Ivan, Jenna.
User avatar
Yuki~
Absolute Otaku
Posts: 2257
Joined: Sep 13, 2006 5:04pm
Gender: Female
Location: Nagoya
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Yuki~ »

I like both.... I don't know which one I like more.. o__o
And ZeianStar, I love the movie/book of The Golden Compass! 8D
olááá
L'Arc~en~Ciel forever~
o(•ω•)o o(•ω•)o o(•ω•)o
quando pousar e abrir os olhos como seria bom se te encontrasse com um sorriso...
tchau~
ZeianStar
Mobile Suit Otaku
Posts: 155
Joined: Apr 27, 2007 12:11pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Inner World
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by ZeianStar »

I also like the Golden Compass the movie and the book.
But I never watched the movie or read the book.
In Weyard train with Isaac, Garet, Felix, Mia, Ivan, Jenna.
User avatar
Yuki~
Absolute Otaku
Posts: 2257
Joined: Sep 13, 2006 5:04pm
Gender: Female
Location: Nagoya
Contact:

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Yuki~ »

Hhmmmmm... I didn't understand very well.. you said you like The Golden Compass, the movie and the book but you never watched the movie or read the book? That's weird... ^^' XD Or I didn't understand...
Anyway.... both movie and book are great! But the book is veeeeery different from the movie! Specially the end! o__o
I'm reading the 2nd book at the moment
olááá
L'Arc~en~Ciel forever~
o(•ω•)o o(•ω•)o o(•ω•)o
quando pousar e abrir os olhos como seria bom se te encontrasse com um sorriso...
tchau~
Hallow
Absolute Otaku
Posts: 3423
Joined: May 31, 2005 12:41pm
Gender: Male
Location: The Enchanted Lands

Re: Lord Of The Rings Or Harry Potter.

Post by Hallow »

LoTR is better. It has a better backstory, it's much more epic, etc etc.
When life gives you lemons you make lemonade, but I say "LEMONS! Screw you life I want some freaking cherries."
I AM CANADIAN
[divinephoenix is my sexy genie]
This sig is owned by [L is my only letter]... She's also my sexy cat girl.
Post Reply