Page 4 of 8
Re: re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 19, 2005 6:59pm
by Mai
He truely did die.
If mcgonagall becomes headmistress who is the transfiguration teacher and who is the DADA, potions teacher(if slughorn doesnt leave )?
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 19, 2005 8:27pm
by animegirl008
Please read this at your own risk as it does give away some of the end.
you have to remember you only have to worry about that if Hogwarts is open. i don't think we'll see a lot of it in the next book either way since Harry said he's not coming back. and the others are going with him.
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 19, 2005 9:12pm
by Mai
i dont think anyone will let him.the ministry, OOTP, ect.know what i mean. too many people will hold him back.
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 19, 2005 9:24pm
by animegirl008
i don't think the ministry can really have a say in what he does anymore. i mean fred and george quit in they're sixth year and nobody made them go back. but i think he just has to much to do to really worry about school. but who knows really. i'm just going on what he said at the end.
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:29am
by Mai
but why would jkr make the 7th year when he wont be in his 7th year?
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 7:34am
by raven_296
I'm quite sure that Harry will be going back to Hogwarts because he wants to be an Auror and you need some of your N.E.W.T level courses to do so. Wasn't Fred and George in there 7th year when they left?
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 8:08am
by Mai
but they didnt take the end of the year exams so how does he know if he got into N.E.W.T level exams?
Re: re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 9:20am
by Yuki's_girl
purple_flamingo wrote:well we know what some of the horcrux were: the diary, the ring and the necklace, and the cup and voldemorts bones are the 4&5 but then whats the 6th one i mean it could be any thing
what do think about that one and also about the R.A.B that was singed on the bottom of the note
i think it was sirius' brother Regulus Black
Wow...I never thought of that. Hmmmmmm, that's a possibility. That would explain why Regulus tried to get out of the Death Eaters...
I read the book in 11 hours or so. I couldn't stop reading. (I skipped dinner and got yelled at by my little brother for "skipping meals for a dumb book".)
Re: re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 10:04am
by Mai
Yuki's_girl wrote:purple_flamingo wrote:well we know what some of the horcrux were: the diary, the ring and the necklace, and the cup and voldemorts bones are the 4&5 but then whats the 6th one i mean it could be any thing
what do think about that one and also about the R.A.B that was singed on the bottom of the note
i think it was sirius' brother Regulus Black
Wow...I never thought of that. Hmmmmmm, that's a possibility. That would explain why Regulus tried to get out of the Death Eaters...
I read the book in 11 hours or so. I couldn't stop reading. (I skipped dinner and got yelled at by my little brother for "skipping meals for a dumb book".)
I've read the book twice now.
Im still searching for glitches in the story that will let us know of more things about harry potter.
Does it mean that voldy is the grerat great great great grand son of Slytherine. If that is so, then how come he didnt get like anything from hogwarts.
Usually people pass down things in wills over generations. I know they got the cup and locket but wouldnt there be more to it. Beccause after all, salazar slytherine loved the dark arts.
perhaps he brought forth the horcrux idea?
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:05pm
by animegirl008
i guess there's only one way to know for sure. so who can say?
Re: re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:19pm
by Serenity
Mai wrote:Yuki's_girl wrote:purple_flamingo wrote:well we know what some of the horcrux were: the diary, the ring and the necklace, and the cup and voldemorts bones are the 4&5 but then whats the 6th one i mean it could be any thing
what do think about that one and also about the R.A.B that was singed on the bottom of the note
i think it was sirius' brother Regulus Black
Wow...I never thought of that. Hmmmmmm, that's a possibility. That would explain why Regulus tried to get out of the Death Eaters...
I read the book in 11 hours or so. I couldn't stop reading. (I skipped dinner and got yelled at by my little brother for "skipping meals for a dumb book".)
I've read the book twice now.
Im still searching for glitches in the story that will let us know of more things about harry potter.
Does it mean that voldy is the grerat great great great grand son of Slytherine. If that is so, then how come he didnt get like anything from hogwarts.
Usually people pass down things in wills over generations. I know they got the cup and locket but wouldnt there be more to it. Beccause after all, salazar slytherine loved the dark arts.
perhaps he brought forth the horcrux idea?
but the cup wasnt even slytherin's...
and I've heard a lot of theories that R.A.B is regulus and it seems about right because the letter was addressed to "The Dark Lord" which only Death Eaters called him but for some reason...I dunno...I kinda doubt it's him...
Re: re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:38pm
by Serenity
Mai wrote:but they didnt take the end of the year exams so how does he know if he got into N.E.W.T level exams?
But he doesnt need to does he? I thought once you have enough OWLS you're in and the 6th year is only for like studying...but I pity the fifth years in the 6th book...they din't get to take their OWLS...
and maybe Harry goes back for a while and then leaves half way through the same way the Weasley twins did...cos he did seem pretty determinded...
re: Harry Potter and The Half Blooded Prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:42pm
by animegirl008
you also have to remember that this is only if the governors decide to open the school back up. while i do think it would be one of the safest places for a child, you know how parents are.
Re: re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 3:42pm
by Yuki's_girl
Serenity wrote:Mai wrote:Yuki's_girl wrote:purple_flamingo wrote:well we know what some of the horcrux were: the diary, the ring and the necklace, and the cup and voldemorts bones are the 4&5 but then whats the 6th one i mean it could be any thing
what do think about that one and also about the R.A.B that was singed on the bottom of the note
i think it was sirius' brother Regulus Black
Wow...I never thought of that. Hmmmmmm, that's a possibility. That would explain why Regulus tried to get out of the Death Eaters...
I read the book in 11 hours or so. I couldn't stop reading. (I skipped dinner and got yelled at by my little brother for "skipping meals for a dumb book".)
I've read the book twice now.
Im still searching for glitches in the story that will let us know of more things about harry potter.
Does it mean that voldy is the grerat great great great grand son of Slytherine. If that is so, then how come he didnt get like anything from hogwarts.
Usually people pass down things in wills over generations. I know they got the cup and locket but wouldnt there be more to it. Beccause after all, salazar slytherine loved the dark arts.
perhaps he brought forth the horcrux idea?
but the cup wasnt even slytherin's...
and I've heard a lot of theories that R.A.B is regulus and it seems about right because the letter was addressed to "The Dark Lord" which only Death Eaters called him but for some reason...I dunno...I kinda doubt it's him...
Hmmmmmmmm, I'm not sure who it could be other than Regulus. Hmmmmmmmmmm...
Wow, this is a long long quote...

Re: re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 6:19pm
by Mai
Yuki's_girl wrote:Serenity wrote:Mai wrote:Yuki's_girl wrote:
Wow...I never thought of that. Hmmmmmm, that's a possibility. That would explain why Regulus tried to get out of the Death Eaters...
I read the book in 11 hours or so. I couldn't stop reading. (I skipped dinner and got yelled at by my little brother for "skipping meals for a dumb book".)
I've read the book twice now.
Im still searching for glitches in the story that will let us know of more things about harry potter.
Does it mean that voldy is the grerat great great great grand son of Slytherine. If that is so, then how come he didnt get like anything from hogwarts.
Usually people pass down things in wills over generations. I know they got the cup and locket but wouldnt there be more to it. Beccause after all, salazar slytherine loved the dark arts.
perhaps he brought forth the horcrux idea?
but the cup wasnt even slytherin's...
and I've heard a lot of theories that R.A.B is regulus and it seems about right because the letter was addressed to "The Dark Lord" which only Death Eaters called him but for some reason...I dunno...I kinda doubt it's him...
Hmmmmmmmm, I'm not sure who it could be other than Regulus. Hmmmmmmmmmm...
Wow, this is a long long quote...

(we all memorized the letter RAB sent to the dark lord. at least I have
)
-In the letter it says that fter destroying the horcrux he will most likely die.in book five, page 112 sirius points out to harry that regulus was killed 15 years ago
-15 years ago voldemort fell for the first time. that same time, or near it Regulus died as well. He not only said that, sirius said that Voldemort had killed him, not personally but regulus betrayed him.(get where im going with this)
-Could it be possible that 16 years ago regulus realized voldemort's plans to kill someone close to him. therefore destroted the horcrux in hopes it will slim his chances of returning. Volemort finds out the locaation of james potter and lilly evans (tipped off by snape)
- remeber when in the first book it said that lilly and james knew someone was coming to kill them but it was too late? perhaps regulus tipped them off so voldemort couldnt harm harry or the parents. So snape , as a last request from voldemort kills regulus?
re: only for those who have read the half-blood prince
Posted: Jul 20, 2005 7:09pm
by Yuki's_girl
DUDE!! Mia, that made so much sense!! Your theroy sounds so plausible. I feel smart!
