Page 1 of 2

Who wins?

Posted: Mar 04, 2008 2:50pm
by Yuki~
I read this in a magazine I bought today and I thought it was pretty interesting! :mrgreen:
So I want to know your opinion!Who would win a fight??

1)Naruto (Naruto) X Edward (FMA)
2)Kakashi (Naruto) X Roy Mustang (FMA)
3)Rock Lee (Naruto) X Armstrong (FMA)
4)Jiraya (Naruto) X Hohenheim (FMA)

(please say your opinion of all the battles! ^^')

* I don't watch Naruto, I really don't like it. I wrote the characters names looking at the magazine, so if there's something wrong, it isn't my fault! XD And sorry if there's already a topic about this somewhere, but I looked for and I didn't find a topic like this out. ^^'

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 05, 2008 10:45am
by Gyro Zeppeli
1) Naruto takes this one

2) Kakashi takes this unless Mustang has one of the fake Philosopher's Stones in Ishbal

3) Same as #2

4) Not enough is know of Hohenheim at this point in the manga, but if he is in fact as strong as the "The Father", then he should take this

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 06, 2008 3:30am
by Aoi Sakuraba
all of the FMA would lose

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 06, 2008 8:18am
by Gyro Zeppeli
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:all of the FMA would lose
Actually, Hohenheim is up in the air. If he is indeed the same level as "The Father" then he should win quite handily

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 06, 2008 1:52pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
Gyro Zeppeli wrote:
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:all of the FMA would lose
Actually, Hohenheim is up in the air. If he is indeed the same level as "The Father" then he should win quite handily
I disagree I think Jiraiya was pwn him to pieces. Jiraiya has fire jutsu and gamabunta and genjutsu....Jiraiya would win.

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 07, 2008 6:38am
by Gyro Zeppeli
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:
Gyro Zeppeli wrote:
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:all of the FMA would lose
Actually, Hohenheim is up in the air. If he is indeed the same level as "The Father" then he should win quite handily
I disagree I think Jiraiya was pwn him to pieces. Jiraiya has fire jutsu and gamabunta and genjutsu....Jiraiya would win.
The Father can disintegrate human flesh from a distance with a thought and can instantly create a homunculus out of his own body from nothing.

If Hohenheim is as strong as Father is, then Jiraiya gets raped


And as for Mustang and Armstrong, with the fake Philosopher's Stones, they are city busters

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 07, 2008 6:37pm
by Karin Rengu
1)Naruto (Naruto) X Edward (FMA) Naruto
2)Kakashi (Naruto) X Roy Mustang (FMA) Kakashi
3)Rock Lee (Naruto) X Armstrong (FMA) hm...
4)Jiraiya (Naruto) X Hohenheim (FMA) hm...

I didn't know Gyro liked FMA! That's interesting

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 07, 2008 7:44pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
Karin Rengu wrote:1)Naruto (Naruto) X Edward (FMA) Naruto
2)Kakashi (Naruto) X Roy Mustang (FMA) Kakashi
3)Rock Lee (Naruto) X Armstrong (FMA) hm...
4)Jiraiya (Naruto) X Hohenheim (FMA) hm...

I didn't know Gyro liked FMA! That's interesting
who doesn't like FMA....it's one of the most popular anime ever made.

As for the Lee/Armstrong.....Lee has insane strength and blinding speed, Armstrong is strong but slow, he'd lose

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 08, 2008 5:20am
by Yuki~
Yeah, who doesn't like FMA??? I just love it!
I'm not going to give my opinion in this topic, because of 2 reasons:
1- I don't watch Naruto, so I don't know these people's power.
2- FMA is my favorite anime. XD

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 08, 2008 11:22am
by Karin Rengu
FMA rocks! but there's a lot of mainstream anime that gyro doesn't like so that is why I was asking

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 08, 2008 9:13pm
by Gyro Zeppeli
I like the FMA manga a lot.

But the anime is how should I say it? Hmmm... disappointing, to say the least

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 09, 2008 4:24am
by Yuki~
I think the anime and the manga are awesome!
But the manga is more complete than the anime. It's so diferent! o___o

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 09, 2008 6:51am
by Karin Rengu
The manga is way better, the anime seemed to be a summary of some sort but having a storyline all its own at the same time. I wish the manga would become an anime!

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 10, 2008 1:35pm
by Yuki~
Yeah, it would be awesome!

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 10, 2008 3:40pm
by Karin Rengu
That'd be so cool! It'd also be nice for the anime to just say "Amestris" instead of avoiding it and saying "the state" etc.
It's pretty lame

Re: Who wins?

Posted: Mar 11, 2008 11:44am
by Gyro Zeppeli
Well, since Naruto won 3/4 of these fights, how about I create some threads where Naruto characters get absolutely murdered?

1. Sasuke vs. ACDC (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)
2. Orochimaru vs. Dark Schneider (Bastard!!)
3. Itachi vs. Vegeta
4. Pein vs. Idea of Evil (Berserk)
5. Sakura vs. Dio Brando (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)