Page 1 of 2
Palpatine
Posted: Mar 31, 2009 5:14pm
by SASSZAIN
Before I let this thread get started, I would like to make one thing clear. THis is not just any other thread about bashing politics. This is a thread about the reality of the situations at hand. I would like to request that if you honestly do not have anything to add to the discussion, please do not post at all.
As I was watching the news today, I had the realization that President Obama is very much like Senetor Palpatine, from the
Star Wars saga.
Here Is a nice blog entry that was submitted in February about the topic. Another early entry, October, can be found
here
When I was first conferring with a friend about this thought, They brought up the subject of the storm troopers. Enter, the
Civilian National Security Force.
[.]
Even though Star wars is fiction, The Obama Administration is a reality.
The things that poke out to me the most about all of this, is:
"People of all ages, stations, and skills will be asked to serve."
This means even children will/could be recruited into this. This reminds me of something that our enemies where doing, not too long ago.
[.] [.] Obama also is getting into the affairs of businesses way to much. For him to ask someone of a public company to Resign, is a large overstep of his authority.
[.]The United States Constitution wrote:Section 2. The President shall be commander in chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the militia of the several states, when called into the actual service of the United States; he may require the opinion, in writing, of the principal officer in each of the executive departments, upon any subject relating to the duties of their respective offices, and he shall have power to grant reprieves and pardons for offenses against the United States, except in cases of impeachment.
He shall have power, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate, to make treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by and with the advice and consent of the Senate, shall appoint ambassadors, other public ministers and consuls, judges of the Supreme Court, and all other officers of the United States, whose appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by law: but the Congress may by law vest the appointment of such inferior officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the courts of law, or in the heads of departments.
The President shall have power to fill up all vacancies that may happen during the recess of the Senate, by granting commissions which shall expire at the end of their next session.
Section 3. He shall from time to time give to the Congress information of the state of the union, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient; he may, on extraordinary occasions, convene both Houses, or either of them, and in case of disagreement between them, with respect to the time of adjournment, he may adjourn them to such time as he shall think proper; he shall receive ambassadors and other public ministers; he shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed, and shall commission all the officers of the United States.
Nowhere in there does it say he has the right, or power, to meddle in the affairs of American companies.
This is what started me thinking of the comparison. Palpatine slowly rose to power through manipulation and motivating talk. The same could be said for President Obama.
Now, it is your turn. What do you think of Obama's power surge? What is your opinion on his Civilian National Security Force? I'm interested to see your various opinions. Please remember to keep posts on topic. Short off topic comments can be made via PMs.
"So this is how liberty dies, with thunderous applause" - Senator Padme Amadala
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Mar 31, 2009 8:52pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
that's quite the interesting comparison. I just think that when amerikans lose all their freedoms I'm gonna laugh and say you wanted change, you got it, now deal with it. With how much power Geithner wants he'll be able to cut in and take over any company he wants and there'll be nothing you guys can do about it.
I don't like big government, I think it gets in the way.
Plus, I think there will be consequences for this whole mentality of "we cant let these companies fail" I mean a basic part of success is failure. If you don't let them fail after screwing up the company then everyone who fails will be standing in line asking for a hand out. If there are no consequences for failure then no one will care if they fail.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 5:56am
by Athos
Ha. A Civilian National Security Force? He should know that there IS a reason for a military. A "Civilian" force will never fly. It'd be struck down by the Courts I'm sure. Unless they use"legal jujitsu." But in that theory, there should be a strong counter argument for it, on the basis of the 9th and 10th amendments. Also, I'm sure common law would speak for itself.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 8:39am
by SASSZAIN
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:that's quite the interesting comparison. I just think that when amerikans lose all their freedoms I'm gonna laugh and say you wanted change, you got it, now deal with it. With how much power Geithner wants he'll be able to cut in and take over any company he wants and there'll be nothing you guys can do about it.
I don't like big government, I think it gets in the way.
Plus, I think there will be consequences for this whole mentality of "we cant let these companies fail" I mean a basic part of success is failure. If you don't let them fail after screwing up the company then everyone who fails will be standing in line asking for a hand out. If there are no consequences for failure then no one will care if they fail.
Quite right. From the very moment i heard that the government was sticking their paws, no their greedy little hands, into the affairs of non governmental companies, I knew things where going wrong. I was right, now many companies are asking for bailouts, because their staff have screwed up. In order to keep America as America should be, the government would have to allow all of the businesses to sort thier things out by themselves. The only real reason that they gave certain companies a bailout, is for the sake of money. Rather than be driven by America, the government seems to me, to just want "More Money"
[.] Not factual, but entertaining, and somewhat relevant.
Athos wrote:Ha. A Civilian National Security Force? He should know that there IS a reason for a military. A "Civilian" force will never fly. It'd be struck down by the Courts I'm sure. Unless they use"legal jujitsu." But in that theory, there should be a strong counter argument for it, on the basis of the 9th and 10th amendments. Also, I'm sure common law would speak for itself.
When I was thinking about how the Obama administration could actually do such a thing, It made me think of the
Selective Service and whether or not the Obama Administration could use that as a means of creating the start of this 'Civilian' Force.
As for the courts striking down his ambitions, I believe that he'll figure out a way to bypass them. After all, he is already slowly eroding away the system of checks and balances that make the government what it is. Just as Palpatine was given extra powers in the time of crisis, It may just be a matter of time before Obama is given the extra powers that allow him to tip the balances in his favor.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 10:56am
by Pennyroyal Tea
First of all, anyone who compares President Obama to Palpatine doesn't have an opinion in my book.
For one, Palpatine sounds like vaginal cream first of all.
Second I love how people are already bashing Obama after less than four months and putting a completely negative spin on every single one of his policies making him out to be some evil Satanic hellspawn
For God's sakes give the man a [censored] chance to work his magic before you begin to bash the man.
And don't get your news from the uber right because they only seek to demonize the poor man, like the uber left glorifies him.
Make this topic in 2 years.
The criticisms he faces is seriously totally unfair, something that no other president has had to face after only three months.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 11:00am
by SASSZAIN
The Joker wrote: First of all, anyone who compares President Obama to Palpatine doesn't have an opinion in my book.
For one, Palpatine sounds like vaginal cream first of all.
Second I love how people are already bashing Obama after less than four months and putting a completely negative spin on every single one of his policies making him out to be some evil Satanic hellspawn
For God's sakes give the man a [censored] chance to work his magic before you begin to bash the man.
And don't get your news from the uber right because they only seek to demonize the poor man, like the uber left glorifies him.
Make this topic in 2 years.
The criticisms he faces is seriously totally unfair, something that no other president has had to face after only three months.
SASSZAIN wrote:Before I let this thread get started, I would like to make one thing clear. This is not just any other thread about bashing politics. This is a thread about the reality of the situations at hand. I would like to request that if you honestly do not have anything to add to the discussion, please do not post at all.
Please, if you have nothing constructive to add, do not post.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 11:10am
by Pennyroyal Tea
SASSZAIN wrote:The Joker wrote: First of all, anyone who compares President Obama to Palpatine doesn't have an opinion in my book.
For one, Palpatine sounds like vaginal cream first of all.
Second I love how people are already bashing Obama after less than four months and putting a completely negative spin on every single one of his policies making him out to be some evil Satanic hellspawn
For God's sakes give the man a [censored] chance to work his magic before you begin to bash the man.
And don't get your news from the uber right because they only seek to demonize the poor man, like the uber left glorifies him.
Make this topic in 2 years.
The criticisms he faces is seriously totally unfair, something that no other president has had to face after only three months.
SASSZAIN wrote:Before I let this thread get started, I would like to make one thing clear. This is not just any other thread about bashing politics. This is a thread about the reality of the situations at hand. I would like to request that if you honestly do not have anything to add to the discussion, please do not post at all.
Please, if you have nothing constructive to add, do not post.
I wasn't, I was speaking specifically about the policy, and the fact is I don't interpret it to be as malevolent as that guy or anybody else that posted in the thread. I was speaking specifically about the interpretation of his policy.
Second, I find it amusing that all I did was counter what was said in the thread, yet I didn't add to the discussion.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 2:49pm
by Athos
The Joker wrote:
The criticisms he faces is seriously totally unfair, something that no other president has had to face after only three months.[/color]
Oh? It seems fair to me, given him putting pressure on Wagoner to resign. And given the fact that he keeps pushing for stimulus packages to shock the economy.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 2:51pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
being under pressure and being criticized is part of being the president. if he doesn't like it or cant handle it he can always quit.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 3:11pm
by Pennyroyal Tea
Athos wrote:The Joker wrote:
The criticisms he faces is seriously totally unfair, something that no other president has had to face after only three months.[/color]
Oh? It seems fair to me, given him putting pressure on Wagoner to resign. And given the fact that he keeps pushing for stimulus packages to shock the economy.
That guy had more than a few months on the job. Like I said, I'm not economics major, that sort of thing doesn't interest me at all, so I can't really speak about how effective his policies are going to be. I just know that he seems to be confident that what he's doing is right, and we all know that he hangs by the rope he makes for himself. Thing is, we should at least give him time to do the things he said he wanted to do.
Aoi Sakuraba wrote:being under pressure and being criticized is part of being the president. if he doesn't like it or cant handle it he can always quit.
He doesn't care about the criticism he receives. However, I'm just making a point that anyone who criticizes the man this early, comes off as foolish even if they know what they're talking about. They're just looking for any excuse to be on his back.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 3:23pm
by Athos
He still had no business forcing out a private employee.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 3:34pm
by Pennyroyal Tea
The Government basically owns GM and Chrysler now though, considering the fact that they just saved their ass. So many people are employed by the company that I don't mind a restructure of the respective companies if it's going to save jobs.
He should be held responsible if he did a bad job. Plus in order for this to be accepted in the eyes of the public, somebody had to be held accountable.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 3:41pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
I don't agree with taking over companies so the don't fail. Failure is part of business.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 01, 2009 3:50pm
by SASSZAIN
The Joker wrote: The Government basically owns GM and Chrysler now though, considering the fact that they just saved their ass. So many people are employed by the company that I don't mind a restructure of the respective companies if it's going to save jobs.
He should be held responsible if he did a bad job. Plus in order for this to be accepted in the eyes of the public, somebody had to be held accountable.
This is exactly the issue.
The government should never "own" a private company at any point. Thats when democracy drifts into Dictatorship. By your own admittance you have supported my argument. Thank you.
Again, I feel I must impress upon you, and anybody else, That I am not bashing Obama. I am merely gathering all of the facts together, to see what is going on. The fact that you yourself think it is bashing, implies that somewhere in your conscious, or subconscious, you are wanting this to be bashing.
As for The Obama Administration's Stimulus, I'll have to do more research, because I've gotten mixed information on that.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 02, 2009 2:25pm
by Pennyroyal Tea
SASSZAIN wrote:The Joker wrote: The Government basically owns GM and Chrysler now though, considering the fact that they just saved their ass. So many people are employed by the company that I don't mind a restructure of the respective companies if it's going to save jobs.
He should be held responsible if he did a bad job. Plus in order for this to be accepted in the eyes of the public, somebody had to be held accountable.
This is exactly the issue.
The government should never "own" a private company at any point. Thats when democracy drifts into Dictatorship. By your own admittance you have supported my argument. Thank you.
.
And like I said, I want the government in charge of both GM and Chrysler since my tax dollars saved the companies. So yes, I want to make sure that they aren't wasted again. This isn't ther first time that they needed government funds, and I don't want to have to worry about saving their ass every 20 or so years because they can't get it together. Without the government's intervention GMK and Chrysler would've failed. They have every right to see that their investment succeeds and that American jobs are saved.
Re: Palpatine
Posted: Apr 03, 2009 7:55pm
by Aoi Sakuraba
SASSZAIN wrote:This is exactly the issue.
The government should never "own" a private company at any point. Thats when democracy drifts into Dictatorship. By your own admittance you have supported my argument. Thank you.
Again, I feel I must impress upon you, and anybody else, That I am not bashing Obama. I am merely gathering all of the facts together, to see what is going on. The fact that you yourself think it is bashing, implies that somewhere in your conscious, or subconscious, you are wanting this to be bashing.
As for The Obama Administration's Stimulus, I'll have to do more research, because I've gotten mixed information on that.
I feel the same I wouldn't want any government running private businesses. I mean think about it, governments are the ones with the most debt and with the worst spending habits and are by far the most greedy of all people. This doesn't just apply to Obama, I'm saying any government.....none of them know how to spend money wisely.