Page 1 of 3

:: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 15, 2005 2:17pm
by Rabid Chibi Fangirl
I've missed most of the eppys and only started watching... is Envy a dude, or a woman? GAH... I know it sounds like i'm an idiot.. but meh.

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 16, 2005 2:32am
by Skyler Wing
I think Envy's a man. But I'm not sure.

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 16, 2005 6:53am
by shuichi_uesugi
I am also stuck on this too. I thought Envy was a girl, but then I heard it was a man. I am so confused! Someone help us!!!

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 16, 2005 12:40pm
by Rabid Chibi Fangirl
It doesn't look very girly because of it's shoulders, but the face looks sorta like a girls. ](*,) And AA doesn't have a profile for her/him yet.

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 17, 2005 8:43am
by rhapsody
im pretty sure he is a man... he may look girly but thats because he likes to look young and cute. they refer to him in the manga as a man

Re: re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 17, 2005 11:23am
by Rikus_Toy
Skyler Wing wrote:I think Envy's a man. But I'm not sure.
she does in a way

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 17, 2005 3:58pm
by Eds girl
Envy is a girl

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 18, 2005 4:28am
by Full Metal
ya she is a girl

but she looks like a man

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 18, 2005 4:57pm
by Rikus_Toy
she looks more like a guy 2 me!

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 18, 2005 5:24pm
by Cherry Darling
Envy is a guy.

He is so old in that he usually takes on the form of a young boy because he "claimed" to forget what his original form looked like.

Major Spoilers:
Spoiler
Show
(Which resembled a teenage Hohenheim) He mainly helps Dante and the other Homunculi by posing as someone to take advantage of people. He imprisoned Greed in the 5th Laboratory.

He was created by Hohenheim when he attempted to use alchemy to revive his and Dante's son, who had died from mercury poisoning. Envy held a great hatred toward Hohenheim for never being acknowledged by the man as his son and for abandoning him and Dante, with whom he has a rocky relationship. But by the time he learned that Hohenheim remarried and fathered two sons, Envy was even more furious and took it out on his “younger half-brothers”, Ed and Al, as it was the next best thing to killing their 'old man'. He even killed Ed, though Al managed to revive him with the Philosopher's Stone. Upon learning Hohenheim is still alive and beyond the gate, Envy went into it in a fit of hatred. The movie reveals that Envy is still alive and is still bent on revenge.

In the manga however, there are no signs of any grudge between him and Hoenheim unlike in the Anime. This may be because of the difference in the Homunculus theory between the two mediums.

Re: re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 22, 2005 6:09pm
by Umi Lothien
BeautifulDisgrace289 wrote:Envy is a guy.

He is so old in that he usually takes on the form of a young boy because he "claimed" to forget what his original form looked like.

Major Spoilers:
Spoiler
Show
(Which resembled a teenage Hohenheim) He mainly helps Dante and the other Homunculi by posing as someone to take advantage of people. He imprisoned Greed in the 5th Laboratory.

He was created by Hohenheim when he attempted to use alchemy to revive his and Dante's son, who had died from mercury poisoning. Envy held a great hatred toward Hohenheim for never being acknowledged by the man as his son and for abandoning him and Dante, with whom he has a rocky relationship. But by the time he learned that Hohenheim remarried and fathered two sons, Envy was even more furious and took it out on his “younger half-brothers”, Ed and Al, as it was the next best thing to killing their 'old man'. He even killed Ed, though Al managed to revive him with the Philosopher's Stone. Upon learning Hohenheim is still alive and beyond the gate, Envy went into it in a fit of hatred. The movie reveals that Envy is still alive and is still bent on revenge.

In the manga however, there are no signs of any grudge between him and Hoenheim unlike in the Anime. This may be because of the difference in the Homunculus theory between the two mediums.
I agree. I have read 40chapters of FullMetal that I know for sure that Envy is a guy. I know the show is diffrent so I will have to find it or find a friend that has is.

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 22, 2005 6:12pm
by Kou Akabane
yup Envys a guy o.o

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: May 31, 2005 10:55am
by Rabid Chibi Fangirl
thanks for clearing it up

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: Jun 05, 2005 6:29pm
by koribabyonln
i've been watching fma since it premeired on adultswim and i've missed the last few episodes but who the hell is envy? Was he/she in the last few episodes that i missed please tell me something. email me, do something. i don't carte if you spoil anything for me, but let me in on this new found info.

koribabyonln@aol.com or koribabyonln@yahoo.com

heaven didn't want me and hell was afraid i'd take over, so they stuck me with earth :twisted:

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: Jun 09, 2005 2:07pm
by animegal93
Envy's a guy. :roll: :-s

re: :: giggles :: A question...

Posted: Jun 11, 2005 1:58pm
by Crystalbear
What anime is this so-called Envy from?