Forum is closed. New registrations are disabled. Join our active Discord community.

Record of Lodoss War - review

Discussions about anything anime-related.
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Dark Lilly »

Record of Lodoss War – Its opening theme gets a ten, but on a scale of 1 to 10, I give the series a 6.5. Formula sword and sorcery. Hero aspiring to be a knight, an elf, a wizard, a cleric, a big strong guy, a thief, dragons, etc. It’s a popular series, but it just never engaged my imagination. I never started to care about the characters. 6 = Worth watching the entire series.
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

Ooops

Post by Dark Lilly »

..
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

I rate it a little higher than a 6.5 I found it quite enjoyable to watch, and cared about the characters. I couldn't help but wonder what would happen to Deedlit and Parn.

Wait, are you rating Chronicles of the Heroic Knight or the 13 eps OVA's?
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Dark Lilly »

Just the Lodos. I watched Chronicles of the Heroic Knight too and didn't care much for it either ..... actually, probably less than the former.

And I am so glad you took the time to politely disagree with me!!!! Commentary is what I was hoping to generate by reviewing a few titles not generally discussed on this site.

Wish a few more folk would review a few things. Oh, well.
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

To be honest, I never even heard of it until a few months ago. It was recommended to me by someone on another forum and I must say that he was right that I would like it. This being a not very well known series probably wouldn't spark much response. I liked it so much because I found it different than most anime I have seen. Kinda like how Last Exile is different. At least as far as I am concerned.

Could you explain a little more why you didn't like it as much? And I'm happy to disagree with you politely. Just trying to be chivalrous :)
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Dark Lilly »

Parn says: I found it different than most anime I have seen. Kinda like how Last Exile is different. At least as far as I am concerned.
++I suppose different would depend on what you have been watching :) I guess it bored me because over the years, I've seen so much sword and sorcery. I'll get back to you with some other titles.

Now Last Exile --- there 's a piece of true art!!! Beautiful as well as unique.

>Could you explain a little more why you didn't like it as much? A
++I didn't hate it. Remember, I did say it was worth seeing the whole series. For whatever reason, none of the characters ever really "got to me" although I did like the relationship that developed between Deedlit and Parn. Could have been due to the art style, the writing or the voice acting. Berserk being one exception to the rule, I'm not a big fan of sword and sorcery, likely because I am an amateur scholar of the middle ages. When it came to Chronicles of the Heroic Knight, I couldn't wait for the last episode so I could be done with it.

>And I'm happy to disagree with you politely. Just trying to be chivalrous
++Living up to your name. I like it, good Sir. Well met.

Dark Lilly
aka: Baroness Isabeau du Lis Noire, Companion of The Laurel, Kingdom of An Tir - Society for Creative Anachronism
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
Parn
Visitor

Re: re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

Dark Lilly wrote:>And I'm happy to disagree with you politely. Just trying to be chivalrous
++Living up to your name. I like it, good Sir. Well met.

Dark Lilly
aka: Baroness Isabeau du Lis Noire, Companion of The Laurel, Kingdom of An Tir - Society for Creative Anachronism
:)

I do whole heartedly agree with you on Chronicles. I was glad when it was over. It might have been because the one little priestest was so young and Spark was older but that part just seemed to bother me.

Some of the voice acting did come off as annoying like Ato's and sometimes Deedlit's but I think some of it was intentional.
Kyle Bloodheart
Visitor

Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Kyle Bloodheart »

I haven't seen Chronicals, but I have seen Lodoss War.

It is worth renting at the most, but I didn't think it is worth owning. When I saw it, I borrowed it from a friend.

The characters just seemed to be steryotypes, instead of original characters. The characters didn't seem to change throughout the OAV either.

So, Dark Lilly, I have to agree with you.
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

Can you explain what you meant about the characters being steroetypical?
Kyle Bloodheart
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Kyle Bloodheart »

The characters just don't seem to have much depth to their personallity. You have a typical wanna-be hero, an Elf that is typically more powerful than most people, a wizard that seems distant, an enemy that only wants to rule the world, and a rival (ashram) to the main character.

I may not be remembering everything, since I saw it about 3-4 years ago. From what I remember, only Ashram had a change of personallity, but even then, he didn't change much.
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

I would agree with you except for a few things. Yeah the main character is a wanna be hero but what I liked most about it is that, he isn't very good. It's obvious that his sword technique is extremely lacking. I know that I haven't been watching anime for too long but from what I've seen, I haven't seen any wanna be heroes. Usually you have the main character that is the best at what he does, kenshin for an example. Also you see Parn constantly going to others to train.
I wouldn't say that the elf wasn't really all that stronger than most. Yeah she had a few powers but they rarely came into play as an advantage. She even needed to be saved by Parn.
I'll give you that the wizard was. . .distant.
But for Ashrum and the Sorcerer, you do kind of need an antagonist to make the show a little interesting. I mean what else would they be fighting for or what would they even do?

I mean feel free to argue with any of this!
Kyle Bloodheart
Visitor

Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Kyle Bloodheart »

I agree with Parn's lack of skill with a sword, but despite this lack of skill, he still beat Ashrum. I never thought, or felt that Parn was ready for a fight with Ashrum.

As for Deedlit, for most of the series, her and Orson, were the only ones who could fight a dark elf. Her magical powers were lacking though.

Ashrum had a slight change in personality when Priortess died to protect him. He turned against Vagnard, and wanted revenge for Priortess' death. Before Priortess' death, he was an uncaring individual.

I actually felt the ending was lacking. After Parn defeated Ashrum, and had both swords, he still had to defeat Vagnard. I was prepared for a fight between Parn and Vagnard, which didn't happen. Parn wins, and we are left wondering how Parn won since Vagnard survived having his head cleaved in two by Ashrum.

As for myself, I haven't been watching anime long either, about 4-5 years. I have only seen what has been on tv, as well as Record of Lodoss War, Hellsing, Vampire Hunter D, and Slayers.

I enjoy arguing topics. It gives me more insight into a topic.
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

I don't think that Parn beat Ashrum. Ashrum and Vagnard kill each other. Ashrum runs Vagnard with his demon sword but not before Vagnard throws a heck of a lot of magic at him. Ashrum spits up some blood and then collapses. I thought that was how it went and then Parn takes up both swords and jumps down to Deedlit.
I assume that Parn hands over both swords to King Kashu. I agree that the ending was lacking where it sees Deed and Parn riding off together looking for Woodchuck.
I haven't even been watching anime for 2 years
Kyle Bloodheart
Visitor

Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Kyle Bloodheart »

It may have gone that way. I don't quite remember the ending, since it was about 3-4 years ago that I saw it, and I felt disappointed with the ending.

After grabbing both swords, Parn jumps down, and lands on a magical barrier. Then it skips to the end.

My friend, and I counted how many lines Orson had, and I think we found that he had about 11-13 lines, and most of his lines had 4 words or less. I think Orson had the best line, "He's in my way."
Parn
Visitor

re: Record of Lodoss War - review

Post by Parn »

I can't help but wonder if you missed some of the ending to Lodoss or maybe I just assumed some things.

It's kind of funny how the OVA's differ from the TV series. Orson had so many lines in it. I found myself thinking that I liked Orson when he hardly ever spoke.
Kyle Bloodheart
Visitor

Record of Lodoss War

Post by Kyle Bloodheart »

I may have forgotten something.
But, what I remember is, after Ashrum died, Parn grabbed both swords, and jumped down onto a magical barrier, in an attempt to breach it, to save Deedlit. Then the scene changes to Parn holding an unconscious Deedlit, outside the fortress. Then the final scene of the series plays out, and the ending credits start. I have never seen the tv series. There may be some references in the TV series that clears up some of the ending of the OAV that you may be remebering. If you have access to the OAV, watch the last episode again, and see if you can clear up our differet thoughts on the subject. I am not in a position to borrow it again.

I borrowed Record of Lodoss War from a friend about 4 years ago, so I may have forgotten something. It was a legit 4 DVD set my friend had.

We may both be correct, just each of us is forgetting something that the other hasn't forgotten.
Locked