Forum is closed. New registrations are disabled. Join our active Discord community.

Consider the following

Topics about anything not related to the other forums.
Locked
Pennyroyal Tea
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2120
Joined: Oct 21, 2005 9:51am
Contact:

Consider the following

Post by Pennyroyal Tea »

I look at America and I see what we have become. In reality I'm really addressing this to the global community because despite the distance between us, we're able to communicate on so many different fronts now, that we're really going to all have to be a part of the problem or the solution. Now this is really about the human condition, and it's going to be kinda hard to pull a deep discussion from this at least on what I say alone, but I bring the challenge to you and everyone to comment on the human condition and bring whatever solution you can come up or if there isn't any solution say why you think so. So basically even though this is the first post in the subject, do not feel obligated to respond only to and about what I say. Feel free to say whatever you want concerning the human condition, social justice, political angst whatever.

I find myself not disappointed in the younger generation as we haven't yet reached the point where we're really controlling the world, but I do find myself upset with many of the established norms that continue to thrive in modern society despite the fact that we're supposedly supposed to be more enlightened than in the past.

In a way, this enlightenment is sorta the cause as there is still a huge ignorant class of people. Now when I say ignorant I mean they're ignorant regardless of racial, social class, sexual orientation, education or whatever mostly based on their lack of caring, different than apathy, about the state of the world in which they live. They're basically sheep wanting to be lead.

And due to this enlightenment that we have reached, basically anyone educated enough to formulate their opinion in an eloquent way is considered intelligent, and while I can't argue against it, eloquence has certainly become a mask that people use to thinly cover their personal prejudice in their attacks on whatever happen to oppose their beliefs. Basically take away their clothes and all their dressings and their message is really. "If you don't agree with me you're a detriment to our society" while I certainly can't argue against this in the application of opinion, I.E see human right, in it's broad application to things like government, healthcare foreign affairs it becomes a problem in and of itself, though despite this these polarizing figures, see Michael Moore, Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh,- seem to be more popular gaining a larger base and as a result we have become more divided as a nation in the last maybe ten or fifteen years than almost any time in society. Why do you think that such figures are gaining popularity? Why are we so divided now? What happened to the same spirit of unity and working together that was so prevalent in the sixties? Nowadays it only seems like we want to work together against someone or something else.

Now I'm going to admit this, in terms of political policy I'm pretty far on the left, however this isn't something that I stick to like glue, it just so happens that if there was an issue, I tend to side with the more liberal of solutions. At best I'd go moderate on occasion, but like I said it really would depend on the issue, it's not like I wouldn't go conservative if I didn't think it was better. Anyway continuing.

Why say this you ask? It's because it seems like all of us, all of us around the world are completely unflinching in all of our goals and opinions. I'll use Obama as an example. Obama does something, now before it even goes in depth on the fundamental nature of his action he's criticized heavily from the right, and defended like you would your own mom and dad from the left. O bush did this two years ago so he's just like bush, or he's the worlds worst president which I'm able to determine based on nine months of his presidency despite the fact that we have yet to feel any real effect of it, and omg you can't say that about Obama he is a great man whatever.

"Wah wah, we can't criticize obama because we're declared racist by the democrats if we disagree with him!" Let's face it conservatives, first of all, this is a complete crock from what I see because I've seen people lambaste the man heavily and not get called anything, if you are faced with criticisms, blame this on your fellow conservatives who ruin your image well by being racist and stubbornly critical despite whatever evidence is brought against whatever platforms they support. I.E see Glen Beck, I.E see Rush Limbaugh.

It's really the same with for the liberals.. "I'm so tired of hearing that we call people racist if they disagree with Obama" You could blame that on your fellow left leaners who seem to take whatever [censored] Obama doles out religiously and think of him as the new messiah. Yes they do exist.


You see instead of becoming part of the solutions we have become part of the problem. We have forgot how to take part in active social discussion not just to disagree with someone, but to reach some sort of solution which is why debate is invented. Not to dehumanize the opponent, no matter how much you disagree with someone they're just as human as you are, and either or in many cases, both of you may be wrong yet until you both accept this you're not going to be able to reach any sort of conclusion on anything really.

So why are we so bitterly divided? Why hasn't the human condition improved despite the many different resources available? Will we ever be different? Will we ever become better? Why have we become a group of people who instead of adapting as the situation benefits as we used to have to do, to trying to find universal answer to every possible situation despite whatever details vary.

"Intervention worked this this one case, so it'll definitely work in this other, let's not worry about analyzing the situation beforehand completely without any sort of bias and instead just go headfirst"? [/color]
Yeah, you were right about me, but can I get myself out from underneath this guilt that will crush me? in the choir, I saw our sad Messiah he was bored and tired of my laments
He said, "I died for you one time, but never again"
User avatar
Dretlin
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2898
Joined: Oct 29, 2004 8:00am
Gender: Male

Re: Consider the following

Post by Dretlin »

I admire your desire to include the entire human race, though I request you be more ubiquitous in your analysis. The world does not stop at the US, nor do the problems that exist. Social or otherwise.

If you want to grab the attention of others, then go beyond American examples. As you lead yourself down the road of the typical xenophobic American that, a minority of, Europeans are so eager to label you as.

Unless this is an issue you want to confine within American politics, which I think you will find that only your countrymen and women will care to reply.
Pennyroyal Tea
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2120
Joined: Oct 21, 2005 9:51am
Contact:

Re: Consider the following

Post by Pennyroyal Tea »

I can only draw conclusions based on what I personally know. It would be too great a leap for me to talk about world policies. However feel free to discuss something of a more global nature. The examples I used all are American because those are freshest in my mind. It's not discriminatory, just an indicator of my lack of knowledge.
Yeah, you were right about me, but can I get myself out from underneath this guilt that will crush me? in the choir, I saw our sad Messiah he was bored and tired of my laments
He said, "I died for you one time, but never again"
User avatar
Athos
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7625
Joined: Feb 17, 2006 7:10pm
Gender: Male

Re: Consider the following

Post by Athos »

Our media has a big role in the mess, and on the next tier telecommunication companies, 5 in which own major newspapers, t.v. networks, etc...Also, there are people (i.e. Ann Coulter, etc...) who only say things just to get publicity, money and or ratings. There is a book that everyone should read, it's called: "Conversations: A History of a Declining Art" by Stephen Miller. Miller accurately points out that since the Enlightenment era, conversation has taken a turn for the worst. He also mentions the qualities a good conversationalists have. It's been a long time since I've read it, but it's what I remember...I'll have to read it again.

But the heart of the issue-I think-the "human condition" (assuming you're talking about social and economic rights) is different between communities such as Europe, America, Latin America, and Asia. With respect to America, Cass Sunstein wrote a book called "The Second Bill of Rights:FDR's Unfinished Revolution and Why We Need It More Than Ever." FDR proposed on Jan. 11, 1944 in a speech that:

Every American is entitled to:

-The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the nation;

-The right to earn enough to provide adequate food and clothing and recreation;

-The right of every farmer to raise and sell his product at a return which will give him and his family a decent living;

-The right of every businessman, large and small, to trade in an atmosphere of freedom from unfair competition and domination by monopolies at home or abroad;

-The right over every family to a decent home;

-The right to adequate medical care and the opportunity to achieve and enjoy good health;

-The right to adequate protection from the economic fears of old age, sickness, accident, and unemployment;

-The right to a good education.

These proposed "rights" or what Sunstein describes as "constitutive commitments" would put forth social and economic guarantees (somewhat) into the American Constitution. Sunstein offers 2possible explanations: (1) chronological -- no constitutions previously adopted before 1900s offers social or economic rights; rights enumerated in the US Constitution understood in the British sense. (2) American Culture & American Exceptionalism -- New Deal era would have certainly pushed (and perhaps even adopted) social and economic rights--but didn't.

The U.S. Supreme Court almost adopted this "second bill." Papasan v. Allain (1986) The Berger court stuck down a Mississippi system in which a state grants funded Native American students. The appropriation amounted to $0.63 (per Native American student) compared to $73.34 (per non-Native American student). The downfall (if you will) was that this decision (and other similar decisions) are limited (meaning that these rulings do not apply broadly, only to narrow situations that may arise under the courts).

I (and probably many others) have no problems with adopting these constitutive commitments. The only problems I see (and which Sunstein admits) is the problem of judicial enforcement.

I have a book (that should be coming in today) called "Weak Courts, Strong Rights: Judicial Review and Social Welfare Rights in Comparative Constitutional Law" by Mark V. Tushnet. It compares social rights in other constitutional republics. From what I've read on the synopsis, Tushnet advocates that social welfare rights are enforceable if a less-stricter mechanism of judicial review is adopted, it may be possible to adopt such rights.

But the probability of that happening, is slim. Something outside of our constitutional norms and practices would have to happen in order for Marbury v. Madison (1803) to be overturned.
Also, these social and economic rights should not be done on the federal level, it should be done on the state level. Such important decisions need to be done on a local level where people's vote are more influential (although, a state like CA--political power is concentrated in the north, but still).

Also, some state constitutions offer such rights. New York for example, bestows a right to a living, and decent wage, and Florida's constitution gives people a right to a job. Going back to what I said earlier, it takes what is happening now to be formed into decent conversation, and to be acted politically.
Member of the ModSquad 8)
Pennyroyal Tea
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2120
Joined: Oct 21, 2005 9:51am
Contact:

Re: Consider the following

Post by Pennyroyal Tea »

There are several ironies about this country, and quite possibly the world at large.

First is the fact that everyone seems to know about media bias and the such, yet we're still so heavily influenced by it.
Second, we're much better educated, this is worldy, than we were lets say, sixty years ago, yet we seem to be easily led.

Now my question is what direction do you think the world is moving in as our generation is about to take over from the older one? Positive negative?

The thing about social issues, and this is more an American thing. Anything that gives rights to the poor will always be denounced as socialist from the right side, bringing a weighty older voting generation into the mix making it hard for any legislation to be passed. Sadly the only solution to this is to get the younger generation more involved in voting and legislative procedures, but the growing apathy amongst the youth is discouraging, and beneficial to the people who benefit from the subjugation of the poor lower class working families. (A lot happen to be minorities) which really discourages any sort of actual progress, though our system is said to be bi-pedal. You're more than likely to stay in the same class you were born in.
Yeah, you were right about me, but can I get myself out from underneath this guilt that will crush me? in the choir, I saw our sad Messiah he was bored and tired of my laments
He said, "I died for you one time, but never again"
Locked