Forum is closed. New registrations are disabled. Join our active Discord community.

THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Discussions about anything anime-related.
Locked
*~Hakkai~*
Visitor

THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by *~Hakkai~* »

:evil: Ok fine... I knew this. Yes, I knew they would be changing the voice actors. But come on!

They 'killed' it! The new people have no life in them. I don't even find Gojyo and Goku fighting as delightful as it used to be. Sanzo is dreadful and don't EVEN ask how f**ked up Hakkai's voice is! How dare they! Sure, tell me it's JUST voice changes. You don't get it. I wrote snail mail to Geneon after I got email from Greg Ayres(Goku) telling me they weren't even asked to do it.. none were.

I can't even see straight I am so pissed off!!!!

I could only watch 2 episodes before switching to subbed. I could cry! I think I did.

Thing is.... I will buy the entire series, of course. But they offer it on ebay at a really cheap price,(subbed only) and if I just can not handle the dubbed... what the hell not buy it. I'm going to look there now.
The Naturalist
Visitor

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by The Naturalist »

You mean the new one that came out recently with Goyjo's hair a different color or the older one?
If youre referring to the new one, I only saw an extended trailer for it, but Goku's voice makes me wanna throw up its so bad.
*~Hakkai~*
Visitor

Re: re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by *~Hakkai~* »

WindChildFuko wrote:You mean the new one that came out recently with Goyjo's hair a different color or the older one?
If youre referring to the new one, I only saw an extended trailer for it, but Goku's voice makes me wanna throw up its so bad.
You know, I was so shocked by the different voices, I didn't even notice the hair color change. Yeah, I believe it's not as red... but this is the same studio that has done Saiyuki since day one. The clothes are different, none of those changes bother me... that doesn't change the character like the voice can.

Like I said, it's been murdered! I don't think I'll get the English version...example here;
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... 87171&rd=1
See? You can get BOTH for the cost of 2 bought here at like Suncoast. No English voices, but what the hell... I'm not happy with them so why not?

:x And I will let Geneon know what I have decided.

:cry: Yes, I am THAT unhappy.
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by Dark Lilly »

And after I just fell in love with the Saiyuki boys!!!! What did they to to my Gojyo???? Nooooo. I loved Illich's Gojyo. I may go straight sub.
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
*~Hakkai~*
Visitor

Re: re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by *~Hakkai~* »

Dark Lilly wrote: What did they to to my Gojyo???? Nooooo. I loved Illich's Gojyo. I may go straight sub.
Hate to say this.... it is NOT Goyjo. Not even close to his banter, dry wit, humor...I don't even recall any kind of remark that would be 'classic Goyjo'. Now that's just sad!!!

HEY!!!! I know how you an hear it!!! You getting my drift, lady?
:P
Guest
Visitor

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by Guest »

Gods! Sounds like we need to shoot the translatear/script wirter too.
mirror_alchemist
Visitor

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by mirror_alchemist »

I have only one question for that. Why? The series just doesn't feel right without the orginal voice actors.
lilc4anime
Visitor

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by lilc4anime »

They sure did, I love the first season it was sooo... good. As for reload Big disappointment how sad for the fans. :cry:
User avatar
Dark Lilly
Ex-Moderator
Posts: 978
Joined: Dec 31, 2004 1:49am
Gender: Female

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by Dark Lilly »

I'm puttin' a yin/yang symbol on my S&W .357 and going hunting at Geneon!

Damn them all to Hell!

The ADV version of the original was one of the best ever (I've noticed ADV does some of the best dubbing around) Not watching another episode in English.

Wish I could get a fan sub of the original Japanese and cut Geneon out of the loop all together. B*****ds.

Sonzo is wooden and stilted in his delivery, Hakkai's voice is too effeminate, Goyjo's voice is blah and stilted and Goku ..... well Goku just isn't right without Greg's raspy voice.

The translated script was also sub par. It lacked the witty repartee' of the ADV script ...... not that the actors could have handled it.

The first person to shoot is the casting director. What were they thinking? I've heard better line delivery from high school drama students and community theatre. Someone want to tell me how these people got SSAG* cards. They got paid scale for ruining Saiyukie!

Dark Lilly "reloading" S&W. "One for the producer, one for the casting director, one for the translator, one for the script writer, one for the director one for ......."

Just kidding. I don't shoot anything but paper targets any more ... and a possum I couldn't get out of my tool shead.

Oh, and thanks *~Hakkai~*!

*Stage and Screen Actors Guild
Stand back! This old Otaku has PMS, a broadsword, a double bladed battle ax, a flail, dagger in her teeth and a pistol in her belt.
*~Hakkai~*
Visitor

re: THEY RUINED MY SAIYUKI!!!!

Post by *~Hakkai~* »

<b>Now now now... no violence!</b> :shock: :lol: :wink: :mrgreen:

<i>Hey, I do have a small yin/yang sticker...hmmmm. Come on! Voice your opinion, no with email.. so easy to delete and forget. As an Amnesty Internationl member for many moons, I know the power letters can generate.</i>


Snail one to;
Geneon Entertainment Customer Service
c/o The Right Stuff International
PO Box 71309
Des Moines, IA 50325

<i>Even if we can't reverse what has been done, we can let them know the consumers are NOT happy. I don't know if I'll get a reply... I have sent 2 now to them.. but I did let Geneon know I would not be buying another Reload/Gunlock with the terrible dub.</i>

6 weeks to get The Milly Thompson coat done for SakuraCon. Just bought the material today. Yeah, that's enough time.
Locked