Aoi Sakuraba wrote:Well, as far as I know English DVD releases have language options. Just select Japanese and English subtitles. With the exception of a few phrases that didnt translate properly or some misunderstood humor, there is no difference between the English version and Japanese version
And you say "you'll even ship them from Japan" but here is the problem with that.....you said you needed subtitles and Japanese DVD's DO NOT have English subtitles. I mean seriously why would we put our DVDs with English subtitles when less than 1% of our population knows enough English to understand it.
I fail to see why Amerikans are so obsessed with the Japanese versions......I has seen many English versions and they dont change much.
Hi Aoi Sakuraba, thank you for the Reply.
My eBay auction DVD sets arrived today, and to my surprise they were actually complete sets, Season 1 and Season 2! Now if I can only find a complete Season 3 somewhere..
You make a very good point about the English subtitles; watching the Japanese DVD's today, they DO have English subtitles but the translation is kind of bad...the main character "Sonic" for example is named "Sonic Rat" in the subtitles. However it was still worth it to me to see the true, uncut versions of the episodes.
Notice I did say "uncut". Here in America, the episodes were dubbed in English and released by 4Kids (a company with a rather poor reputation among anime fans here); their version of the episodes is extremely censored...no bad language, some of the things like explosions and fight scenes are cut completely out, and such.
But perhaps the biggest single event change was the last 2 episodes (77 and 78), where one of the main characters (Cosmo) was killed. The original Japanese version made me very sad when I watched it, but sad because it was so
good. It was tragic, but it also very moving emotionally and it was beautifully done. The version aired here in America on the other hand, was severely edited and most of the dialog was changed entirely.
Why is this a big deal? Well, here in America we have some pretty dedicated anime fans. We love our shows here and when a company takes liberties with the story/language/dialog, fans tend to get quite angry. It may sound silly, but we almost take it personally. Sonic X, while not as mainstream as many other series', has a solid fan base and a lot of us consider the 4Kids version to be a very weak, poorly-done copy of the Japanese original.
To put it another way, if someone says "yes I've seen Sonic X", the response they usually get is "the English version isn't worth watching...watch the Japanese one instead!"
And so I'm doing exactly that.
I hope that helps answer your final statement on why some Americans are obsessed with the Japanese versions of shows. You're right in saying that many shows are basically the same in both countries...Sonic X, however, was one that suffered pretty badly when it was dubbed to English and aired here. It didn't completely ruin the show, but it took away many parts of the series that were very enjoyable.
Sorry to have made such a long post.

But I hope it helps explain why I'm looking for this so hard. And again, thank you for taking time to Reply.
