Remember if it was too powerful with no drawbacks then it would likely be banned, 4 star monsters dont go much over 1900 ATK, 6 star dont go over 2500 ATK and 7+ stars over 3000 ATK unless they have a major effect drawback (except for Black Luster Soldier-Envoy, i hate that card
My first attempts would be..
Effect Monster/Dark/Spellcaster/4 star
Magician of Hope
ATK 1600 DEF 1100
Effect - This effect may only be used once during your standby phase. Discard one card from your hand to add 1 spell card from your deck to your hand, your deck is then shuffled.
and to go along with it..
Fusion Effect Monster/Dark/Spellcaster/5 star
Magician of Miracles
Magician of Hope + Magician of Faith
ATK 1900 DEF 1500
Effect - This effect may only be used during your standby phase. Once per turn you may add 1 spell card from your deck or graveyard to your hand.
